Daughtry Sued By Former Bandmates For Fraud, The Apple Doesn't Fall Far From The Tree Options

[Hoodstock]

Apparently Daughtry really does look to his friend Ed as an example:

By The Hollywood Reporter

"American Idol" season 5 finalist Chris Daughtry has been sued by his former bandmates over royalties, Greensboro, N.C.'s News & Records reports.

Bassist Ryan Andrews, drummer Scott Crawford and guitarist Mark Perry -- who joined Daughtry in the band Absent Element prior to "Idol," MyFox Memphis reports -- filed a lawsuit on Thursday in Guilford County Superior County claiming that Daughtry defrauded them out of royalties from four songs, including music and lyrics, that the group had written together.
Advertise | AdChoices

Jennifer Hudson's star power may complicate murder trial

The trio's lawsuit cites "constructive fraud, breaches of fiduciary duty, unfair trade practices and other deceptive and wrongful conduct" on the part of Daughtry.

Daughtry posted a brief statement on his official band website in response to the allegations on Friday: “I am very hurt by these false accusations. The songs listed in this lawsuit were written solely by me and no one else and at this time, I have no further comment.”

Daughtry was a fourth place finisher during "Idol's" 2006 season which saw NBC "Smash" star Katharine McPhee face off with winner Taylor Hicks in the finale. His band Daughtry was formed that year.

http://entertainment.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2...-for-fraud?lite

[Opinechik]

LMAO....I read this yesterday and wondered why it hadn't hit the board yet.

[+AllOverMe+]

Once again, one of my favorite frontmans rapes his (former) band mates.

[World Dreamer]

"Your mysterrrrrrryeeeheeeeee heeeeeeeee....keeps on getting me sued..."

[SinfulEyes]

"Your mysterrrrrrryeeeheeeeee heeeeeeeee....keeps on getting me sued..."

I'm sure Chris now wishes he had never met Ed.. HAHA

[OutToDry]

They should have sued his fucking ass too for his Idol rip off......that always rubbed me the wrong way........still does.



Somehow I feel perhaps Ed smoothed that over when it was a big deal......Daughtry.....just another manufactured phony in the music industry.

This post has been edited by OutToDry: Apr 9 2012, 6:20 pm

[themaestro]

Can't stand Daughtry. Possibly more annoying than Stapp.

[PillarOfDavidson]

Can't stand Daughtry. Possibly more annoying than Stapp.

I know this will probably get me black-balled around here, but I actually liked Creed's music a lot back in the day. We shouldn't blame Stapp's "wonderful" disposition on the melodies. Besides, to hate on Creed is to hate on Alter Bridge because the music from both bands came from the same people. If you're a fan of Alter Bridge and not a fan of Creed then possibly you could look at Creed's music as early demo's of Alter Bridge before they added a real singer/songwriter.

[themaestro]

I know this will probably get me black-balled around here, but I actually liked Creed's music a lot back in the day. We shouldn't blame Stapp's "wonderful" disposition on the melodies. Besides, to hate on Creed is to hate on Alter Bridge because the music from both bands came from the same people. If you're a fan of Alter Bridge and not a fan of Creed then possibly you could look at Creed's music as early demo's of Alter Bridge before they added a real singer/songwriter.

I like some early Creed stuff. Definitely like Myles way better than Stapp though.

[OutToDry]

jerkyboy was hurt by their words.....very very hurt!!!

Rocker Chris Daughtry says he is "very hurt" by a royalties suit filed by his ex-bandmates. The former American Idol finalist has been accused of defrauding bassist Ryan Andrews, drummer Scott Crawford and guitarist Mark Perry out of royalties from four songs.

The musicians, who played with Daughtry in the band Absent Element, claim they wrote the tracks' music and lyrics with the singer.

The trio cites "constructive fraud, breaches of fiduciary duty, unfair trade practices and other deceptive and wrongful conduct" on Daughtry's part, according to the suit filed on Thursday and obtained by North Carolina's News & Record.

However, Daughtry has hit back at the allegations in a brief statement on his website, which reads, "I am very hurt by these false accusations. The songs listed in this lawsuit were written solely by me and no one else and at this time, I have no further comment."

hmmmm...sounds like a scheming manager again and the fool.....nee Chris D

[OutToDry]

Charlotte Observer has a more complete newsbrief:

http://www.charlotteobserver.com/2012/04/0...s-daughtry.html

Former bandmates sue Chris Daughtry

3 former members of Absent Element say they are owed royalties for 4 songs.

By Steve Lyttle
slyttle@charlotteobserver.com

By Steve Lyttle The Charlotte Observer
Posted: Friday, Apr. 06, 2012

Modified: Saturday, Apr. 07, 2012 Chris Daughtry

Home might be “where I belong” for pop music star Chris Daughtry, but it also is the place where he faces a lawsuit from his former bandmates.

Three former members of Absent Element, the band which featured Daughtry as lead singer before he became a contestant on “American Idol” and a highly successful recording artist, filed suit Thursday in Guilford County Superior Court.

The three are seeking royalties from “Home” and three other hit songs they say they have a share of.
Daughtry, who lives in the Guilford County town of Oak Ridge, responded late Friday by saying he was "very hurt by these false accusations."

In the suit, the three claim they had a role in writing the songs -- or should have gotten a share of royalties because they, along with Daughtry, had agreed to share revenues equally.
Daughtry, who is scheduled to appear in concert Monday night at Ovens Auditorium in Charlotte, disputed the claims.

"The songs listed in this lawsuit were written solely by me and no one else," he said.
At stake could be millions of dollars. Daughtry is the third-ranking “American Idol” contestant in terms of record sales and concert profits, trailing only Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson -- and the most successful non-winner of the event. He finished fourth in the show’s 2006 season -- and has been far more successful than the season’s winner, Taylor Hicks.

Ryan Andrews, Scott Crawford, Mark Perry and Daughtry were attending Integrity Community Church in Burlington in 2004 when they decided to form a band, which eventually became known as Absent Element. Daughtry was lead vocalist and played guitar; Perry was lead guitarist and backup vocalist; Andrews played bass guitar; and Crawford was the drummer.

According to the lawsuit, “All four members wrote music and lyrics for Absent Element’s songs, collaborated on the arrangement and recording of those songs, regularly consulted with each other on matters relating to the business of the band, and made partnership decisions based on majority votes.”
The suit spells out what the three former band members say were their specific jobs. Andrews and Perry, for example, designed the group’s website. And Crawford, with the help of Andrews and Crawford’s family business, created Absent Element T-shirts, which were sold to fans.

The band recorded an album, “Uprooted,” in late 2004, and in the suit, they acknowledge that a disagreement over how to share revenue nearly caused the group to break up. But they eventually reached an agreement, they say.

“Daughtry shared this understanding ... and conducted himself in a way that reflected that understanding,“ according to the suit.
The three plaintiffs also say the April 2006 copyright of songs on “Uprooted” shows that all four members had equal interests in the lyrics and music.

In the suit, the three former band members say they agreed in autumn 2005 that Daughtry’s audition for “American Idol” could help Absent Element become more successful, especially since, at the time, there was no reality TV show available to music groups.

But that proved to be the beginning of the end of the relationship.
Daughtry auditioned for the show that autumn in Denver and despite a negative vote from judge Simon Cowell (he won the support of Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson), Daughtry was picked to advance. He eventually reached the 24 finalists and continued in the competition until being eliminated in early May 2006.
In the suit, the three former band members say Daughtry wrote “Home” during the time he was competing on “American Idol,” but they say he began working on the song before that. The three other songs at issue in the suit are “Breakdown,” which the plaintiffs say they performed together as Absent Element; “Conviction”; and “Sinking.”

The band’s final performance was in June 2006, in Greensboro. That was shortly before Daughtry went on the annual summer “American Idols” tour. And about the same time, according to the suit, Daughtry told the group to stop using his name in connection with Absent Element’s album and website -- an action Daughtry said was required by the producers of “American Idol.”

Daughtry’s self-titled first album was released in November 2006 and sold about 6 million copies. That was followed by another successful release in 2009, “Leave This Town,” and then “Break the Spell” in 2011.
In the suit, the three former members say they have not received credit as being co-writers of the four songs, nor have they received royalties.

They are represented by Raleigh attorneys Charles Coble and Coe Ramsey.
Daughtry isn't responding beyond his denials.
"At this time, I have no further comment," he said.

Read more here: http://www.charlotteobserver.com/2012/04/0...l#storylink=cpy

good comment in the comments section:

..."and has been far more successful than the season’s winner, Taylor Hicks."

Of course he has. It's called MARKETING. While Sony Records kicked Hicks to the curb without so much as a video & advance single, they pulled out all the stops to launch Chris Daughtry as a credible artist. They put him in a manufactured band, and gave him songwriting credits on songs he barely had a hand in. Check out the controversy about who really wrote Daughtry's first hit "It's Not Over". Think about it, you don't suddenly turn into a hit songwriter just because you were on a singing competion. Every aspect of the band DAUGHTRY was created, controlled and orchestrated by Sony Records and 19 Entertainment. I doubt Chris Daughtry even owns the rights to the band name "DAUGHTRY" I guess that's the way the music industry works, but to hear that he took sole credit for "Home" and other songs that his former bandmates co-wrote, well that's over the line.

another spot on comment!!!

Actually, the poster knows exactly what he's talking about because the strategy he describes is commonplace in the business I've worked in for twenty years. I'm no Taylor Hicks fan (his "soul" is pretty fraudulent, actually), but Daughtry, like Rascal Flatts, Nickelback, and other acts, is a product of a record company's formulaic marketing strategy. Put something photogenic out there in the media stream and on a Wal Mart end-cap in a big way for an extended amount of time, and the public WILL buy it as long as it's simple enough for them to understand and bland enough to not challenge them. Welcome to 21st century American pop music.

Vonmansteni 1 comment collapsed - Oh Dome of Chrome Oh Dome of Chrome where are thouuuuu..... royalities!

sounds like another famous chrome dome.

This post has been edited by OutToDry: Apr 9 2012, 8:33 pm

[PillarOfDavidson]

Trying to find talented musicians of integrity you can trust, who aren't narcissistic careerist assholes, is like trying to find gold and diamonds up your friggin' nose.

CCP are lucky to have each other.

[+Ed+]

If only we all knew, how Absent Element was MILES better than everything Chris has done since he started a solo carreer.

Quite similar, oh yes.

[Merica]

Would be a shame if he turns out to be a douchebag, as I do quite like him and his music as a rule.

[World Dreamer]

I know this will probably get me black-balled around here, but I actually liked Creed's music a lot back in the day. We shouldn't blame Stapp's "wonderful" disposition on the melodies. Besides, to hate on Creed is to hate on Alter Bridge because the music from both bands came from the same people. If you're a fan of Alter Bridge and not a fan of Creed then possibly you could look at Creed's music as early demo's of Alter Bridge before they added a real singer/songwriter.

Their first album was really good. After that I thought Creed was sort of average.