All over You - 2011 Recording, Fresh recording with NEW lead singer Options

[Aitkens]

I've been a number of Ed shows, the LIVE songs always sound good.

No, they don't. We've already established that you have a horrible ear for music.

[Merica]

I've been a number of Ed shows, the LIVE songs always sound good.

Compared to his new music? Sure, because, in and of themselves, they're far better songs. But compared to how Live USED to perform them - how they should sound... very debatable.

[SJN1279]

No, they don't. We've already established that you have a horrible ear for music.

To be honest, an acoustic Ed Kowalczyk show is the most authentic LIVE show any of us can get at this point.

[Merica]

To be honest, an acoustic Ed Kowalczyk show is the most authentic LIVE show any of us can get at this point.

I disagree. Maybe in the superficial sense of Ed being the recognisable lead singer / voice. But authenticity should come down to the group's initial principals, what they stood for, what the shows meant, what the band was about.

Is that Ed today? Or is it CCP?

Hmmmmm........

[PillarOfDavidson]

I disagree. Maybe in the superficial sense of Ed being the recognisable lead singer / voice. But authenticity should come down to the group's initial principals, what they stood for, what the shows meant, what the band was about.

Is that Ed today? Or is it CCP?

Hmmmmm........

It was always about the group rather than an individual. When the band ceased to function as a group and started to function more as the outlet for one individual is when it ceased to be authentic Live. It essentially became The Edward Kowalczyk Band.

CCP have returned it to authentic status now that they've gotten the LSD-infected problem out of the way.

This post has been edited by MrSheptical: Dec 29 2011, 7:28 pm

[Hoodstock]

To be honest, an acoustic Ed Kowalczyk show is the most authentic LIVE show any of us can get at this point.

[SJN1279]

I disagree. Maybe in the superficial sense of Ed being the recognisable lead singer / voice. But authenticity should come down to the group's initial principals, what they stood for, what the shows meant, what the band was about.

Is that Ed today? Or is it CCP?

Hmmmmm........

CCP with a Blind Melon reject on vocals? I will take the primary songwriter and voice of LIVE.

This post has been edited by SJN1279: Dec 29 2011, 7:32 pm

[PillarOfDavidson]

CCP with a Blind Melon reject on vocals? I will take the primary songwriter and voice of LIVE.

Better a Blind Melon reject than a Chris Daughtry wanna be.

[SJN1279]

Better a Blind Melon reject than a Chris Daughtry wanna be.

Um, Ed came first. Daughtry emulated Ed.

[PillarOfDavidson]

Um, Ed came first. Daughtry emulated Ed.

Which makes it all the more sad that Ed is trying to emulate Daughtry.

[VoodooLady]

Suck my teet. You know you want it.

What are we? 12? lol hahahaa

[OutToDry]

To be honest, an acoustic Ed Kowalczyk show is the most authentic LIVE show any of us can get at this point.

Now you move the goal posts again and reference ed acoustic solo. Holy shit Batman, we're not talking about that...what so
ever. Spinning again after ownage.

[SJN1279]

Now you move the goal posts again and reference ed acoustic solo. Holy shit Batman, we're not talking about that...what so
ever. Spinning again after ownage.

You're entitled to not like Ed's new musicians, just as I'm entitled to think that LIVE with a new singer is a horrible idea.

[Live4Life]

You're entitled to not like Ed's new musicians, just as I'm entitled to think that LIVE with a new singer is a horrible idea.

[OutToDry]

Um, Ed came first. Daughtry emulated Ed.

Daughtry is a douche, he sang Walk the Line (Live's version) and didn't credit them, he got caught and then had to fess up. Daughty is everything that is wrong with the music industry. American Idol shit. When Live was on there, I yawned very hard, I actually felt bad for them. I knew those guys probably did it as a last gasp.