Dan's Secret Album, Request Options

[Existentialist]

Even $125 is well worth it to people like me. Do you realize how rare it is for something like this to come along? It's happened once in the 12 years or so of Live fan sites. If someone had studio Change and Mallrat for sale, I'd pay more than $125 just for the two of them. Hear that, people with Change and Mallrat?

[Nedra]

Sharing is nice.

I can see how having something "valuable" for trade would be nice, too.

Me? I just want to HEAR them!

lol

If I had the money and it was still for sale, I'd probably not hesitate to buy it.

I'm old. I've been listening to LiVE from the very beginning.

It'd be worth it to me.

[SecretInsomnia]

Well let's take a look at the list...

-------------------------------------------
• Where Fishes Go (with guitar intro and alternate ending)
• Deeper (alternate version with sitar)
• Feel The Quiet River Rage (with alternate ending featuring a sitar)
• Sun (with a few alternate lyrics and choir in the middle)
>>> Well I don't have these songs, but maybe they can be intersting. Sun with a choir: that can be cool. FTQRR and Deeperwith a sitar: must also be different from the origininal). The only one I would be interested in is WFG, just only for the intro.
-------------------------------------------
• Dance With You (with a few alternate lyrics)
• Sparkle (with a few alternate lyrics)
• Meltdown (with a few alternate lyrics)
• Voodoo Lady (unmixed demo version)
• They Stood Up For Love (unmixed demo version) [big bang version]
• Don't Wait (unmixed demo version)
>>> These titles sound maybe interesting when you've never heard this, but these are all already available (via the mp3 thread J Sax offered to us or on 'Pilgramage to the Southern Stars'), or are just worse versions of songs/demos we already have (great, an unmixed version of a song, while you already have a better version).
-------------------------------------------
• Overcome (full band studio version)
• Still Aroused (studio version)
• Walk Into This Room (Ed solo)
>>> only these three tracks would be really worth it to every fan I guess. At least, they deserve the be called 'rare'. But I must honestly say it's not what I expected from it. The quality is very oke, it's just cool to hear it because it's so rare, but it's not something really special. Still aroused sounds in song structure really like the crappy live version, but just good studio. But it doesn't make it anything unheard. Nice to hear once in a time, but there's really a good reason Live did not released these 3 tracks for the audience
-------------------------------------------

realising this all (although I don't have all these song), I just can't believe that anyone want to spent $ 125,- to get this? Maybe 20 or $ 25,- but nothing more!

[Hoodstock]

Usually there is a good reason why songs go unreleased. With the exception of Vine Street and Cheetah I can see why all of the unreleased Live songs I have heard have been kept off of albums.

Again, if anyone would be willing to post or share these versions I would be interested in hearing them.

[+Ed+]

Just one more simple question to the ones who possess the copies.

Have you ever made a bargain, exchanging the tracks you have for even more super unreleased quazi rarities even Ed can hardly remember of?

I just really wonder why they are so tightly kept, if EdStipe and Ex themselves publically claimed to be freely sharing them?

[jpochas]

Yeah I am trying to trade up these tracks for other rare ones. I've had one person interested simply because of full band Overcome, but a trade hasn't materialized yet. I'm also not freely sharing anything!

[+Ed+]

Yeah I am trying to trade up these tracks for other rare ones. I've had one person interested simply because of full band Overcome, but a trade hasn't materialized yet. I'm also not freely sharing anything!

Why not?

[Hoodstock]

Why not?

Great question. I'm willing to share with anyone who's note here soley for downloads.

[jpochas]

You also don't have jack shit to offer, either.

[Hoodstock]

You also don't have jack shit to offer, either.

You have no idea what I actually have . Depending on your song library I may or may not have anything to offer you.

By the way is your other name Existentialist because he talks like you and discusses this big trade just like you mentioned!


This post has been edited by Hoodstock: Apr 23 2008, 7:18 pm

[jpochas]

Of course I'm Existentialist!

[Existentialist]

No he's not!

[Hoodstock]

Of course I'm Existentialist!

No he's not!

Ex - you never fail to amuse me. Keep up the good posting!

[+Ed+]

No reasons given, no PM answered. That is how modern-days men behave. Keep it up.

[PurdueSteve]

• Overcome (full band studio version)
• Still Aroused (studio version)
• Walk Into This Room (Ed solo)
>>> only these three tracks would be really worth it to every fan I guess. At least, they deserve the be called 'rare'. But I must honestly say it's not what I expected from it. The quality is very oke, it's just cool to hear it because it's so rare, but it's not something really special. Still aroused sounds in song structure really like the crappy live version, but just good studio. But it doesn't make it anything unheard. Nice to hear once in a time, but there's really a good reason Live did not released these 3 tracks for the audience

I'm interested in these 3 tracks, anyone that has them PM with a request for something you're looking for and maybe we can trade.

With that in mind, I think it's quite pompous that people refuse to freely share material. If you're a "fan" than you're a fan. If you're selling this material then you are a thief. It's one thing to immoral capitalize when you're not a fan, but when you're supposedly a fan and you do the band a disservice such as this, it makes you a pretty shitty fan.

Any "true" fan would freely share the material because he or she realizes that there are other fans out there wishing to experience the music that they love.