Song vs. Song, A new game for us Live fans! Options

[Pokey]

Susquehanna easily, in my top 10 live songs (especially that rhode island uni gig, I dont think Ed's voice has sounded better) .. Deeper bores me.

ok I'm gonna try a different spin, you're gonna have to come up with which one is less crap..

Home vs Love Shines

[Wambangalang]

game over

[LiveRoCkS77]

Susquehanna easily, in my top 10 live songs (especially that rhode island uni gig, I dont think Ed's voice has sounded better) .. Deeper bores me.

ok I'm gonna try a different spin, you're gonna have to come up with which one is less crap..

Home vs Love Shines

Neither one is exactly crap. Not the greatest songs but certainly not crap.

They may be that to you, but I think that has more to do with your age than anything else. I also think calling a song that a man writes for his children is completely disrespectful and ignorant. I'd be completely offended as a father myself if I wrote something for my girls, and you called it crap and I'm sure Ed would be too.

It's fine if you think it's crap, but just plain disrepectful and idiotic to repeatedly announce it.

[Pokey]

I'm not repeatedly announcing it I am working it into this fantastic game for someone to choose from.

I don't really care if you or Ed think it's disrespectful, I still think it's crap and it has nothing to do with my age. If Ed wants to write songs for his daughters then that's awesomeness, if he's going to release them on an album for the whole world to hear then he's gotta expect to cop flak for it. I can appreciate the fact he wrote it for his daughters, cool, but it doesn't mean I gotta like the song, it doesn't automatically put it into some amazing special catergory where you can't diss it either. Hey personally I think Home is a worse so for the record so I'd choose Love Shines.

So .. stop de-railing the thread and..

Home vs Love Shines

[Merica]

I think it's a tough one. Both aren't Live's greatest work, equally so, so it's hard to pick. However, pick I must, and so I choose....Home.

[LiveRoCkS77]

I'm not repeatedly announcing it I am working it into this fantastic game for someone to choose from.

I don't really care if you or Ed think it's disrespectful, I still think it's crap and it has nothing to do with my age. If Ed wants to write songs for his daughters then that's awesomeness, if he's going to release them on an album for the whole world to hear then he's gotta expect to cop flak for it. I can appreciate the fact he wrote it for his daughters, cool, but it doesn't mean I gotta like the song, it doesn't automatically put it into some amazing special catergory where you can't diss it either. Hey personally I think Home is a worse so for the record so I'd choose Love Shines.

So .. stop de-railing the thread and..

Home vs Love Shines

No, you are derailing the thread with your nonsense. End of that story.

Second, nowhere did I say you HAVE to like the song. Pay attention little boy. I can appreciate the fact you don't care for it, no problem with that. COMPREHEND so far?

The fact that you are repetitive on the matter indeed shows that it does have something to do with your age. I've heard you state this point over and over and goddamn fucking over again over here and at friendsoflive. Get over it already. I mean, are you seriously a retard who says the same thing over and over again because they can think no farther? If not, what's your excuse? Because all I can think of is that you're rather immature and with you being just a young boy, it makes perfect sense.

Now seriously, AGAIN (since you are a fan of repetitiveness), how many times have you repeated this? What's your point? YOU THINK IT'S CRAP. OOOOOOKKKKKKKKK

"HEY EVERYONE, EAMON DOESN'T LIKE SFBM, FOR THE 3 THOUSANDTH TIME"

We get it and that's my point. You being repetitive on the matter is what I'm calling disrespectful. You not caring what I or Ed think again showcases your outright ignorance, and one day, you're gonna get knocked the fuck out for it. It's the way of the world son. Say what you want once and get away with it but say it in the wrong place and you're gonna end up picking your teeth up off the floor. Not saying it will happen in any particular realm of discussion but if you take this attitude of not caring who you disrespect, eventually it will happen. So learn some manners and learn to respect people in the same way you expect people to respect you.

[Pokey]

No, you are derailing the thread with your nonsense. End of that story.

No I didn't derail the thread, a simpley continued on with the game giving it a new twist, you just got your panties in a twist over it, that ain't my fault

"HEY EVERYONE, EAMON DOESN'T LIKE SFBM, FOR THE 3 THOUSANDTH TIME"

"HEY EVERYONE, LIVEROCKS IS A DICK, FOR THE 3 THOUSANDTH TIME"

I honestly wasn't writing an essay about it .. it was an offhand comment which gave me a fun chance to have a pot shot at it .. grab a sense of humour dude and learn to lighten up .. it's not as if I posted a massive rant on it.


lol I love that "it's the way of the world son" .. like that's what happens, people just go around knocking each other out because they disagree .. ok sometimes that does happen but anyone who resorts to phsyical violence over it is a dick. And I can proudly say I've never been punched out ever, SCORE!
It's not that I don't care who I disrespect it's the fact that if my opinion upsets someone then that's their problem not mine.

Jesus christ why are we still even arguing about this, if you get that worked up over a tiny little pot shot I took in good fun I'd hate to see what would happen if some guy keyed your car, you'd probably disembowel him.

[aLIVEinNORWAY]

Home vs Love Shines

Wow what happend to all the nice people around here

Home vs Love Shines.
Love Shines to me.
I think it's great , no mather what some of you think and one of my fave from SFBM.
And yes I like SFBM.

Heres one for you:
The first singel from SFBM The River or the New rockin first singel from their multi platinium selling new album

[Pokey]

huh ? .. the river vs ... ? whats the first single from their multi platinium new album?

[LiveRoCkS77]

You didn't derail the thread? Is that why the first poster after you declared game over? Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmjm...............................

Quit twisting diagreeing versus repetitive disrespect, there's a massive difference.

For instance, I could take you calling me an asshole or an idiot to my face a few times and chalk it up to the fact you think I'm a dick. BUT, keep on with it over and over and over again, showing me a complete lack of respect, and I would wipe the floor with your ass. An example in reality for instance is that a guy at my work poked me in the chest when I asked him to leave. I told him not to touch me and actually warned him against it. After further argument, he poked me again and this time I told him that if he touched me again that I would break the fucking arm he touched me with. Guess what? He didn't like that and decided to disrespect me further and poke me even harder. So I proceeded instantly to grab him by the throat and toss his stupid ass to the floor. Security was no nicer to him neither and he was banned from the property.

See the point? I'm just saying that there is no need for the constant badgering on the subject. It is rude and outright fucking disrespectful, completely different from disagreeing. I honestly respect the fact that you were severely disappointed with SFBM. But I have no respect for the fact that you are CONSTANTLY blabbering on about it, every chance you get. I don't give a fuck what you say about it, it's disrespectful, plain and fucking simple.

Your statement that you don't care about disrespecting Ed says something about you big time. as a fan, say that to his face why don't you? Say it when a certain generous person gave you the chance to on the aussie tour? I bet you didn't and I'm betting it's the same reason you've not yet gotten your ass kicked. Most likely because you behave nothing in person like you do here. I hear you're quite timid in person and won't say much. Which tells me that you DON'T disrespect people often in person. So there's your difference son.....SCORE? I don't think so.

And the guy that keys my car? Nah, no disembowelling....just a date with his forehead and the car bumper.

[Pokey]

You didn't derail the thread? Is that why the first poster after you declared game over? Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmjm...............................

Quit twisting diagreeing versus repetitive disrespect, there's a massive difference.

For instance, I could take you calling me an asshole or an idiot to my face a few times and chalk it up to the fact you think I'm a dick. BUT, keep on with it over and over and over again, showing me a complete lack of respect, and I would wipe the floor with your ass. An example in reality for instance is that a guy at my work poked me in the chest when I asked him to leave. I told him not to touch me and actually warned him against it. After further argument, he poked me again and this time I told him that if he touched me again that I would break the fucking arm he touched me with. Guess what? He didn't like that and decided to disrespect me further and poke me even harder. So I proceeded instantly to grab him by the throat and toss his stupid ass to the floor. Security was no nicer to him neither and he was banned from the property.

See the point? I'm just saying that there is no need for the constant badgering on the subject. It is rude and outright fucking disrespectful, completely different from disagreeing. I honestly respect the fact that you were severely disappointed with SFBM. But I have no respect for the fact that you are CONSTANTLY blabbering on about it, every chance you get. I don't give a fuck what you say about it, it's disrespectful, plain and fucking simple.

Your statement that you don't care about disrespecting Ed says something about you big time. as a fan, say that to his face why don't you? Say it when a certain generous person gave you the chance to on the aussie tour? I bet you didn't and I'm betting it's the same reason you've not yet gotten your ass kicked. Most likely because you behave nothing in person like you do here. I hear you're quite timid in person and won't say much. Which tells me that you DON'T disrespect people often in person. So there's your difference son.....SCORE? I don't think so.

And the guy that keys my car? Nah, no disembowelling....just a date with his forehead and the car bumper.

Gee that's a lot of words on the internet.

Get over it, it was an off handed tongue in cheek comment, actually I didn't even read any of what you just wrote there.

[Wambangalang]

err...i said game over as a joke. As in: "Home vs. love shines.....gee, how could anyone pick from two utterly reprehensible choices. game over..."

har har har

[LiveRoCkS77]

Gee that's a lot of words on the internet.

Get over it, it was an off handed tongue in cheek comment, actually I didn't even read any of what you just wrote there.

That your only response jerk off? You use that one a lot!!!

But as I remember it on FOL, you made quite a few posts half a page long....hmmmmmm

Anyways little boy, you are a joke. Just offering you a bit of advice before you disrespect the wrong person and get your little douche bag head kicked in.

Also, I think we've all heard enough of your "tongue and cheek" comments when it comes to how SFBM is so bad. If you add all your repetitive retard blubbering on here about it, it would be enough to fill 60 pages in an entire thread.

Now that's what I call a lot of words on the internet, idiot.

[K. Schrader]

christ, guys, calm down already especially you, LiveRoCkS77.
Pokey's comments about SFBM do have some substance about them, and he is correct that SFBM in light of Live's other efforts seems rather mediocre, and everyone should be able to agree with that.

Note very carefully i did NOT say it was bad, just then, i like the album quite a lot, but its certainly no TC, TDTH, MJ or SS.

...Never will be...

And another thing, forum taunting and use of swear words like you were trying to intimidate someone in a face to argument, on the internet, that's just stupid. End of story on that one.

Just thought i'd say this since i like to come to this forum and read clever and interesting discussion (should i keep coming then? ) and hate it when i have to read posts of insufferable, immature arguments for half of each page.


...and what about that 'first singel from their multi platinium selling new album'?

P.S: personally i prefer the demo version of Home over Love Shines; Ed's use of third person in the demo version for home just fit much better from my perspective. Sounds so preachy and overdone in the album's version. Again, both songs aren't too special either way, but i believe whole heartedly that almost all of SFBM's songs (bar the final 3 songs and Show) should've been kept completely acoustic, maybe even on an unplugged type set. That would've been cool.

[LiveRoCkS77]

christ, guys, calm down already especially you, LiveRoCkS77.
Pokey's comments about SFBM do have some substance about them, and he is correct that SFBM in light of Live's other efforts seems rather mediocre, and everyone should be able to agree with that.

Note very carefully i did NOT say it was bad, just then, i like the album quite a lot, but its certainly no TC, TDTH, MJ or SS.

...Never will be...

And another thing, forum taunting and use of swear words like you were trying to intimidate someone in a face to argument, on the internet, that's just stupid. End of story on that one.

Just thought i'd say this since i like to come to this forum and read clever and interesting discussion (should i keep coming then? ) and hate it when i have to read posts of insufferable, immature arguments for half of each page.
...and what about that 'first singel from their multi platinium selling new album'?

P.S: personally i prefer the demo version of Home over Love Shines; Ed's use of third person in the demo version for home just fit much better from my perspective. Sounds so preachy and overdone in the album's version. Again, both songs aren't too special either way, but i believe whole heartedly that almost all of SFBM's songs (bar the final 3 songs and Show) should've been kept completely acoustic, maybe even on an unplugged type set. That would've been cool.

Blah blah blah blah blahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblahblah......talk about half a page and write one?

Did you not comprehend when I said I don't mind his negative opinion of the cd? You blind? I don't care if ANYBODY thinks it's bad, that's their perogative.

Repeating it a million times in every thread, every forum, at every opportunity is what is childish, immature and disrespectful.

Fuck, is that not comprehendable or do I need a retarded interpreter to explain it to you?