Let's have some fun, Making the worst Live CD possible Options

[mfitz804]

How many times have people said 'I'd rather listen to the worst Live album than the best album of a lot of other artists"? Well, lets test that theory. I am going to run a poll for each album, and also a b-sides/unreleased poll and a covers poll. We'll pick the least favorite songs on each release. I will then take the results and make a CD of the least favorite Live songs of this board and listen to it in my car for an entire week. We'll see if I love it or hate it. I encourage others to play along at home.

Please vote, it doesn't work without you.

Mike

[mikkel]

I really like your idea
I voted Libra, good luck with your polls and maybe I'll get myself a Worst of Live-cd too

[teressa]

Cool idea! Funny, I had thought of burning a cd of all the songs I usually skip
to see if they would grown on me or not but haven't gotten around to it. I'll be
interested to hear your results.

Had to go with Ball and Chain on this one.

[mfitz804]

Its nice to see other people as crazy as I am.

My plan is to put the one worst from DOAD, the 2 worst from each album, and the worst b-side and worst cover. That should fill up an 80 minute CD nicely. If that won't all fit, I'll have to figure out what to drop. If its not enough, I may have to do a run-off with some 3rd place songs.

Once completed, I will compile the results and post the track list so people can burn their own.

This post has been edited by mfitz804: Jun 10 2006, 9:42 am

[tswart1]

I always thought Good Pain was like a Mental Jewelry B-Side. Its from Four Songs.

[mfitz804]

I always thought Good Pain was like a Mental Jewelry B-Side. Its from Four Songs.

Well, technically its from DOAD, then Four Songs, then Mental Jewelry. Its on all 3. Four Songs isn't an album, its an EP, a demo done for the record label prior to them taking the plunge into the full length album.

I will NOT be doing a Four Songs poll. I will include Heaven Wore A Shirt and Negation on the b-sides poll, though neither should win IMHO.

[Rodman91]

interesting idea...anxious to see how this turns out (of course, the problem is that there are 10 songs on BOP worse than anything on TC, but...I digress...)

this one was fairly easy for me...

Hands of a Teacher

By the way, disappointed with the Ball and Chain votes...boooooo...

[fearisnottheend]

Excellant idea mfitz. I thought about making a cd with all the songs on each album that i skip but never did it. Once you get a complete list made i'll make the same one and try this little experiment with you.

[mfitz804]

(of course, the problem is that there are 10 songs on BOP worse than anything on TC, but...I digress...)

That's why I made it some from each album, so the BOP, V, and SFBM haters couldn't say "I already have that CD, its BOP/V/SFBM".

And come on, a three way tie? Work with me people!

[Pokey]

They just released their "worst of" , it's called Songs from Black Mountain - out now on sony epic!

[mfitz804]

They just released their "worst of" , it's called Songs from Black Mountain - out now on sony epic!

Thanks for being "that guy".

[sandkind]

They just released their "worst of" , it's called Songs from Black Mountain - out now on sony epic!

sorry mate, i respectfully disagree and believe it to be BOP. SFBM is a close second, though.

[mfitz804]

This is what I was hoping to avoid by including the worst off EACH album. The last thing this room needs is another thread debating the quality of BOP and SFBM, or comparing the two.

[mfitz804]

I'd like to see if we coul dget 25-30 votes on this, that'd be good enough for me. Come on people, point and click!

[sandkind]

don't get ya undies in a wad, i voted, but still the worst song on most of the earlier discs is better than the best on later ones, IMO.