York, PA, Friday November 9, 2012 Options

[OutToDry]

I didn't know you were going, last I read you were still debating on whether or not you wanted to attend, but then struggled with the thought of spending any money on Ed (which I don't blame you.). Maybe next time I was only there for half the show, it wasn't my intention to stay the whole time, just enough to say hi to Ed, give him a present, and then leave.

I noticed from your YouTube clips they are from start of song to end of song, did you record the moments in between songs? Did you record anything between the end of I'm the Proof and the next song?

-Jimmy

Karmaburgers mmmmm

[dancing queen]

I didn't know you were going, last I read you were still debating on whether or not you wanted to attend, but then struggled with the thought of spending any money on Ed (which I don't blame you.). Maybe next time I was only there for half the show, it wasn't my intention to stay the whole time, just enough to say hi to Ed, give him a present, and then leave.

I noticed from your YouTube clips they are from start of song to end of song, did you record the moments in between songs? Did you record anything between the end of I'm the Proof and the next song?

-Jimmy

Jimmy, I was really torn and I didn't actually spend any of my money on Ed. (though I did buy Kingsfoil cds, which I'm really enjoying more and more). I had asked my roommate to go (and buy tix) but he had to be somewhere. Then my friend who I took to see Live in March told me she bought us tickets. it was pretty awesome of her. so I went.
and no, I didn't record any of Ed's chatting w the crowd. I had to rest my wrists because holding my phone to record was exhausting. why? did something happy after I'm the Proof that I should've recorded?

[OutToDry]

see above

[dancing queen]

Karmaburgers mmmmm

whatever it was, I definitely didn't see it.

[dangum]

Here are some real nice front row videos taken by a fan that travelled from France to see this show:

The Beauty of Gray
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qzvpns8EpY4

The Distance
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K91ZbJ9740E

The Garden
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e_akt-11cuE

Turn My Head
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LONLePZyMW4

Overcome
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fvd1SVFlUAA

[SJN1279]

http://www.ydr.com/opinion/ci_22009716/our...oses-and-thorns

ROSES: To former Live lead singer Ed Kowalczyk for his recent show at the Pullo Family Performing Arts Center. It sure would be great to see him reunite with his old band.

[themaestro]

http://www.ydr.com/opinion/ci_22009716/our...oses-and-thorns

ROSES: To former Live lead singer Ed Kowalczyk for his recent show at the Pullo Family Performing Arts Center. It sure would be great to see him reunite with his old band.

THORNS: To those that seem to forget. Ed voluntarily left Live for a solo career and was replaced by someone that wanted to be in the band.

[Lerxst]

ROSES: To former Live lead singer Ed Kowalczyk for his recent show at the Pullo Family Performing Arts Center. It sure would be great to see him reunite with his old band.

That would be the WORST IDEA and WORST THING THAT COULD EVER happen to the band, and they know this full well! (I make sure to remind them every time I see them ha!)

Nick, what the hell is the point of posting a quote like this? Is that also your private wish? For Ed to reunite with his old band? I mean I know it's Ed's wish. What? Don't believe me? Ask him sometimes I mean you constantly disrespect CCCP and bag on the guys and TGF and their businesses and what they do, but yet you would post this quote about Ed getting back together with them?

Do you agree with the newspaper quote? I find it, like yourself, completely disrespectful of the band Live and their current lineup. They know full well Chris Shinn and NOT ED KOWALCZYK (thank God) is the new lead singer, yet they would say something like Ed should get back with his old band. If that isn't a sign of complete disrespect for Chris and the guys, I don't know what is. The notion of a reunion - oh wait..hang on... thanks.. I almost vomited in my mouth - yes the notion of a reunion is ridiculous and would NEVER HAPPEN!

Stop posting offensive and propagating disrespect to Chris and the guys. They have a new lead singer, they have moved on! Ed should do the same and move on with his solo career, stop using the name Live for his own financial gains and think about what he's done to his old buddies and the knife he planted in between their shoulder blades.

This post reminds me of your stupid campaign to get Ed to come back to the band... done ALSO WHILE knowing full well Chris is the new band member. Again - completely disrespectful but then you are like Ed so I shouldn't be too surprised.

REUNION with ED? JUST SAY NO!!!!!

-Jimmy

[Pokey]

Of course Nick wants Ed back in Live, not because he values CCP as musicians and song writers, he's made that clear that he doesn't, and not because it would improve anything from a musical stand point since Ed's solo work has no noticable drop-offs ... no, the only reason Nick wants Ed back in Live is so that he can LEGALLY attach himself to the name and sell more tickets and make more money.
This ladies and gentlemen, is a "TRUE" Live fan, and not a single word of this can be disputed by him lest he completely contradicts arguments he's been making for years.

[Live4Life]

Ed voluntarily left Live for a solo career and was replaced by someone that wanted to be in A band.

Fixed your post.

[themaestro]

Fixed your post.

Doesn't change my point one bit.

[Lerxst]

Fixed your post.

Wow!!! Great COMEBACK!! How long did that take you? Did you stew on it all night long? Or do you actually have something useful to contribute to this conversation? You rock Diane!

-Jimmy

[Lerxst]

Of course Nick wants Ed back in Live...

Nick that's just silly of you. Why would you want Ed back in Live? Now this response I can't wait to hear from you? We all know that Ed dearly wants to get back with the guys, but what makes you think that the guys would want that? First of all they're respectable people (unlike your hero) and they wouldn't do that to a guy like Chris. They've made their choice! They're extremely happy and Live finally is a band again, so not only would they disrespect themselves and their new bandmate but the notion that the band would even be open to that is silly. It won't happen Nick. But let's play devil's advocate, let's assume that it happens, you think the guys would love to see you around at shows or backstage? I mean after all your endearing words about them? LOL.. Well hell, maybe they wouldn't I know I would love to meet up with you again for old time's sake. Seriously though, you need to get off that bandwagon about any possible reunion with the guys and your hero Ed. It's not gonna happen that pipedream of yours.

-Jimmy