New lyrics: Shinn or Group effort?, Ned: Please stay out of this thread Options

[themaestro]

WAS

Where else can you get the lowdown on why Live has a DJ or the real reason they brought in CS as the singer?

[Pokey]

This is the best place for Live news.

Yeah but you'd find out that news eventually anyways and people dont contribute anything substansive so we should all just leave and find news elsewhere, or we could stay and refuse to leave because this place is good for info... Oh god my brain hurts from the "logic".




I'd guess for the most part Shinn is the principal lyric writer with the others having suggestions for input or suggestions for themes for the music they created to give Shinn a starting point on where to write... Be interesting once it's out to hear the stories of how the new songs came together though.

[thefunkyredcaboose]

Poke, come check out the Live board at thegraciousfans.com.

[themaestro]

Since Chris is only there because they can control him does that mean they force him to write the lyrics or they write the lyrics and force him to sing. When does he give them the money?

[themaestro]

What about the DJ? Since he is there to mask Chris's vocals does he get involved in the lyrics and consult on what lyrics he can mask better than others? Just curious how this all works.

[dancing queen]

I have no intention of ever defending Nick, however, preemptive attacks on his douchebaggery aren't actually necessary/pleasant/what I come here for.
How many people must I now put on ignore? I read the 2nd page thinking Nick had said something ridiculous. Unless i missed something, people are digging up stuff (I do remember him saying) from other threads and making sarcastic remarks. I feel like it's what I'm always accused of in an argument as a women (bringing up stuff long forgotten from forever ago as if it's relevant to current issues - and maybe everything Nick's doing IS relevant to some, but I like to try to be a grown up and I'm working really hard to maintain positivity, so each day is a new day. I have him on ignore. If the thread appears to be civil, I'll read a post of his. If civility is maintained, I'll read and respond to his posts like he's a regular human just like anyone else here. If the douchebaggery continues, I'll go right back to the ignore system. it's not that hard.)

also, did people really leave? I should explore more around the board... .that seems silly to me. I can understand family members of the band and such deciding they don't need the drama, but OTD - who I am eternally grateful for for getting me into the York show - really left? I must've missed something. Oh well, no need to derail this thread, but there's no way I would let anyone chase me off the one place Live fans can gather round the campfire.

On topic - I'm fully under the assumption that CS is the main lyricist, and the rest of the guys create songs together based on what he's written, or maybe they've written some music and he's added some lyrics. I wouldn't be surprised if CT has a lyrical influence/contribution, though. I know he dabbles (and it's good - he can dabble all day, as far as I'm concerned). I feel like, the more the merrier!!

[themaestro]

Nothing wrong with a little sarcasm in the face of what has been spewed around here for years as far as I'm concerned.

[dancing queen]

I love sarcasm. I live it all day long.
But hewhoshouldnotbespokenof gets so vicious and catty and ridiculous, I'd just rather see him completely and totally ignored, rather than goaded. Even if it is funny and accurate.

[Hoodstock]

(CT) I know he dabbles (and it's good - he can dabble all day, as far as I'm concerned).

Are we still talking about music?

This post has been edited by Hoodstock: Aug 30 2012, 10:58 pm