How is "New Live" going to differ from TGF? Options

[mfitz804]

I mean really. Its CCP with a different singer, throw an extra guitar player in there too. New Live is going to be CCP and a new singer. Is it just going to be the fact that the new singer is going to sing old songs?

Can I be expected to believe that CCP's music with New Live will somehow differ from CCP's music in TGF?

What's the difference going to be, really?

I suppose only time will tell.

[tiger]

I mean really. Its CCP with a different singer, throw an extra guitar player in there too. New Live is going to be CCP and a new singer. Is it just going to be the fact that the new singer is going to sing old songs?

Can I be expected to believe that CCP's music with New Live will somehow differ from CCP's music in TGF?

What's the difference going to be, really?

I suppose only time will tell.

New Live is to TGF as old Live is to TGF, which is to say they are nothing alike. TGF is a totally different animal. I don't even get the question. I mean, old Live is also C,C,P with a different singer vs. TGF, so shouldn't it sound just like TGF but with a different singer? No. The analogy fails because TGF is old school rock music. So unless Live is all of the sudden going to be an old school rock band, it will be nothing like TGF.

[mfitz804]

New Live is to TGF as old Live is to TGF, which is to say they are nothing alike. TGF is a totally different animal. I don't even get the question. I mean, old Live is also C,C,P with a different singer vs. TGF, so shouldn't it sound just like TGF but with a different singer? No. The analogy fails because TGF is old school rock music. So unless Live is all of the sudden going to be an old school rock band, it will be nothing like TGF.

Maybe I didn't explain myself. Assume that CCP are writing the music they want to write with TGF. Their beef with old Live was lack of creative input. We can assume that New Live would be music they want to write. Are you trying to say that they would write one genre of music for New Live, and a different one ("pld school rock") for TGF?

I'm not saying they would sound identical.

This post has been edited by mfitz804: Sep 27 2011, 10:01 am

[Hoodstock]

Maybe I didn't explain myself. Assume that CCP are writing the music they want to write with TGP. Their beef with old Live was lack of creative input. We can assume that New Live would be music they want to write. Are you trying to say that they would write one genre of music for New Live, and a different one ("pld school rock") for TGP?

I'm not saying they would sound identical.

BTW -- what the hell is TGP? You have it 3 seprate times in 2 different posts.

[mfitz804]

BTW -- what the hell is TGP? You have it 3 seprate times in 2 different posts.

TGP would be a typo. I think it was pretty clear I meant TGF.

Maybe I was subconsciously trying to be cool by spelling "Few" with a "Ph".

You've revealed my inept typing. I'll go back and edit.

This post has been edited by mfitz804: Sep 27 2011, 10:02 am