FULL STUDIO GUILTY FEVER!, on amazon now! Options

[Existentialist]

[Infrequent Poster]

TROY > Silly Thing imo.

I'm gonna have to disagree with you there! Silly Thing is the pop rock song of the album. It's got a light, vibrant, feel without forgoing the "rock" part of pop rock like so many songs today do. TROY, while a good song, just doesn't have that same push behind it that Silly Thing does. TROY is a good kind of "chill out" song; something I can play on the radio at work and everyone will bob their heads to it. Silly Thing is something that I can also play at work but instead of just head bobbing there'd be some head banging.

It's awesome, though, that you can make a good debate as to what the "best" song on this CD is and not remove any song from the conversation. While I may disagree with some choices I can respect all of them. How long has it been since we've had a Live album where you could pick ANY song off of it and make a convincing case it was the best of the album? Was there any Live CD you could do that?

MJ? Maybe.
TC? No, Horse is easily excluded compared to the rest of the album.
SS? Maybe, though Century and Merica would be hard cases, at least from where I'm standing.
TDTH? We Walk in the Dream would be excluded.
I'm not going to include the last three albums for obvious reasons.

The only song I see that you couldn't make a good case for on the TGF CD is What's Wrong. However, I'm withholding judgment until I hear the studio cut as I was not hot for TROY when I heard it on the Fat Daddy's boot but have grown to love the studio cut of it.

This post has been edited by Infrequent Poster: Sep 8 2010, 4:20 pm