If "Alive" Was A Live Album Options

[LiveFan92]

Forget all of the recent crap for a moment... If "Alive" was a Live album and all of the boys had played their parts, etc... where would you rank it? Obviously not in the band's top 4, but what about in comparison to the post 2000 stuff? Better? Worse? The same?

[ItchyTriggerFinger]

Forget all of the recent crap for a moment... If "Alive" was a Live album and all of the boys had played their parts, etc... where would you rank it? Obviously not in the band's top 4, but what about in comparison to the post 2000 stuff? Better? Worse? The same?

I'd have to rate it as worse just because of the number of songs on it that I simply can't stand. There are probably three or four tracks that I'd swap out in a heartbeat for the two bonus tracks that aren't on the U.S. released CD. With those changes, I'd put it on part with SFBM. And I'm on record as not hating SFBM.

The one issue I'd have would be the same issue I had with SFBM and was put best by a friend of mine. Both albums lack that song or set of songs that makes me want to test just how high my car stereo can go while barreling down a highway.