This is a sin, yeah I know he is allowed to play it Options

[OutToDry]

Ugh. Not the same. The musicians cannot deliver on this one. Sorry My honest opinion



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TEQTOQloi5w

[beau99]

Ugh. Not the same. The musicians cannot deliver on this one. Sorry My honest opinion



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TEQTOQloi5w

I'd much rather Ed play it with his new band than have Kevin Martin raping it.

[Pokey]

I'd much rather Ed play it with his new band than have Kevin Martin raping it.

If KM does a bad job then they'd probably just be as bad as each other, but I doubt he'd do as bad a job as a group of amatuer musicians.

[sh4rpz]

If KM does a bad job then they'd probably just be as bad as each other, but I doubt he'd do as bad a job as a group of amatuer musicians.

whatever happens, it's not gonna be the same as LIVE with Ed. That's for sure.

Some of us will like the old material being re-done by TGF and Ed, others won't.

Heck, I remember in the Paradiso DVD thread some time back, we were opposed to the way Ed changed the lyric in Operation Spirit and who could forget the way he said 'Spirit'?! One comment I remember (not sure who tho), did it perfectly as 'SPIII-RAT!' or something, which was spot on!

LIVE meant (or means) a lot to everyone posting on this board here. There will be contrasting opinions on what should and shouldn't be covered and how it should be done etc.

We're all in it together for the long one, because LIVE gave us these great albums in MJ, TC, SS and TDTH - whoever is gonna be covering them will hopefully do justice to it. I'm of the opinion, that Ed and his band haven't. That is just what I think tho. I think he should perhaps leave the LIVE stuff alone. I know many are with me.