Which Song Do You Like More?, Appetite or Zion? Options

[Hoodstock]

This goes along with my original idea months ago that a "Side Projects" thread should be created instead of a seperate thread for EddieK and TGF.

Anyways, if you've heard them both which song do you prefer?

[Schlomo]

I really want to say I love Appetite and Ed's song sucks but deep down I'm probably more drawn to Zion. I'm not a musician at all so the number one thing that stands out for me when listening to music is the vocals.

As much as I love what TGF are doing, Kevin Martin just doesn't do it for me. It definitely sounds like something I could enjoy spinning from time to time, but as far as filling the Live void? Not even close. It sucks because I want TGF to blow Ed out of the water and become my favorite band but for me they already have a very limited ceiling.

Ed's voice is what got me hooked on Live. That said, Zion isn't that good of a song and Ed's a d-bag so I probably won't listen to him much, if at all.

Combine the passion of TGF with Ed pre 2000 or whatever and we'd probably have some kickass music.

[FishOutaWater]

I really want to say I love Appetite and Ed's song sucks but deep down I'm probably more drawn to Zion. I'm not a musician at all so the number one thing that stands out for me when listening to music is the vocals.

As much as I love what TGF are doing, Kevin Martin just doesn't do it for me. It definitely sounds like something I could enjoy spinning from time to time, but as far as filling the Live void? Not even close. It sucks because I want TGF to blow Ed out of the water and become my favorite band but for me they already have a very limited ceiling.

Ed's voice is what got me hooked on Live. That said, Zion isn't that good of a song and Ed's a d-bag so I probably won't listen to him much, if at all.

Combine the passion of TGF with Ed pre 2000 or whatever and we'd probably have some kickass music.

That's the thing. Appetite (and probably TGF) doesn't fill the Live void. It's nothing like Live. Frankly, The EK and Zion come pretty close to filling the Live void. Zion isn't bad at all in that regard.

TGF is totally different. I really love The White Stripes and Audioslave and Godsmack and Led Zep. Appetite rocks me like that. It put hair on my chest just listening to it. Zion and Everlasting Love take hair off my chest. That's not a bad thing if I want to feel all mystical and
filled with love and peace. But if I want to get my blood boiling, then it's TGF. These two parts of Live are splintering in different directions.

This post has been edited by FishOutaWater: Jan 5 2010, 5:19 pm

[LiveFan92]

I have to pick Zion since TGF doesn't actually want people listening to their song!