Question to people who consider "The Turn" a Live album Options

[dangum]

Here is a question for those who consider "The Turn" a Live album:

Should Ed release a studio album containing new tracks, reworked Goose Blackstone songs, with his new group of musicians and then sticks the "Live" logo on it - would you also consider it an official Live album?

[Plive]

The Live album I want is the unreleased songs album with all songs not released from 1998 era plus more.

As 3/4 of the real Live seem to do other things with Chad Gracey rambling on podds, Patrick invisible and Chad Taylor seem to be on constant vacation I rather have a new album with Ed’s cover band than nothing regardless what he wants to call the band.

I really don’t understand why they keep the outtakes in the drawer.

[tbone2004]

The Live album I want is the unreleased songs album with all songs not released from 1998 era plus more.

As 3/4 of the real Live seem to do other things with Chad Gracey rambling on podds, Patrick invisible and Chad Taylor seem to be on constant vacation I rather have a new album with Ed’s cover band than nothing regardless what he wants to call the band.

I really don’t understand why they keep the outtakes in the drawer.

I'm waiting for an anthology compilation of Live at this point. If the band truly is done for, then the least they could do for the hardcore fans is release all the unreleased stuff. Hell, they could release all the early Public Affection stuff and people would buy it!