Why wouldn't you want Live to get back together?, Other side of the coin. Options

[SJN1279]

I know that many of us would like to see Live get back together in some form, but I'm curious as to why some of us don't. Seeing all sides of the issue is always a good thing, and it would be interesting to see the responses.

[SuperHans]

The band may not be as commercially successful with Chris Shinn however they do seem to have found their ability to rock.

If Ed came back I think we may end up with something like BOP again and given that they are an older band now Id' say that their commercial success would be limited anyway even with Ed in the band.

Ed has his shows and his fans go to them, Live have their shows and their fans go to them.

I've been to both and enjoyed both, Live with Chris was better than Ed and his band, but I'm happy to see them both separately. With an Ed show you know what you are going to get and with a Chris show you know it won't be as polished but it will be loud and energetic.

I'm happy with things the way they are.

Hans.